Our Menus

Loyalty Program

Earn 1 point for every dollar spent on online orders.
Once you accumulate 200 points, you will receive a reward in the amount of $10.00 towards any online order.

Redeem the coupon at any time by clicking Enter Coupon button at checkout.
When you register AFTER your first order - you will automatically be enrolled and start earning points.

Download Our App

Downloading our App is simple! Just log on to our web site from your phone and you will automatically be prompted to download our App. We will only prompt you the first 3 times you visit the site and then only every once in a while. Follow instructions and save to your home screen. Our logo in the form of an icon will then be stored on your home screen. Any time you feel like accessing our site or placing an order just click on the icon and you are on your way!

City Island Seafood Shack Takeout Menu For takeout only with a $1.99 online convenience charge. To place an order click the link below Available: 11:30 am to 9 pm, 7 days Order Online Raw Bar Available in house only Appetizers Baked Clams Oreganata $11.95 Fried Calamari w/ Spicy Marinara $12.95 Mini Crab Cakes w/ Spicy Remoulade $12.95 Lobster Mac & Cheese $13.95 Buttermilk Chicken Tenders $10.95 Shipwreck Fries Topped with crabby cheese sauce. $13.95 Beef & Cheddar Empanadas $9.95 Shrimp Empanada $9.95 Peel & Eat Shrimp (1lb.) Old Bay steamed. $19.95 Soups & Salads New England Clam Chowder $6.95 House Salad Add grilled shrimp for add'l charge. $6.95 Crispy Calamari Salad $13.95 Bowls Served with garlic bread The Mussel Sucker Bowl Marinara or garlic & butter. $14.95 The Clam Digger Bowl Marinara or garlic & butter. $16.95 Peel & Eat Shrimp Bowl Old Bay steamed. $17.95 Baskets Served with fries, slaw & tartar Traditional Fish & Chips Basket $15.95 Jumbo Fried Shrimp Basket $15.95 Fried Calamari Basket $15.95 Fried Flounder Basket $16.95 Combo Basket Flounder, shrimp & calamari. $19.95 Sandwich Board Served with fries & slaw Beer Battered Cod Sandwich with tartar sauce $12.95 Grilled Salmon BLT Sandwich with creamy dill $12.95 Crab Cake on a Bun with spicy remoulade $13.95 Famous Lobster Grilled Cheese $13.95 Fried Shrimp Po Boy $13.95 Fried Flounder Patty Melt Served with American cheese. $13.95 Fish Tacos with jalapeno slaw & cilantro crema $13.95 Shrimp Tacos with jalapeno slaw & cilantro crema $13.95 Shack Cheese Burger $10.95 Buttermilk Fried Chicken Sandwich $12.95 Broiler Served with yellow rice & vegetables Broiled Shrimp Scampi $17.95 Pan Seared Salmon $19.95 Broiled Flounder $17.95 Stuffed Shrimp $21.95 Combo Pots Snow crab, shrimp, clams & mussels Low Country Boil Combo Pot Snow Crab Legs, Shrimp, Clams, Mussels, Kielbasa, Corn on the Cob & Yellow Rice Simmered with Old Bay Seasoning and our Special Garlic Butter Recipe. $49.95 Sides Side of Sour Cream $.5 Side of Salsa $.5 Side of Cocktail Sauce $.5 Side of Tartar Sauce $.5 Side of Creamy Dill $.5 Side of Cilantro Crema $.5 Side of Honey Mustard $.5 Side of Spicy Remoulade $.5 Side of Sweet Chili $.5 Side of Pico de Gallo $1 French Fries $4.95 Side of Slaw $3.95 Corn on the Cob $2.95 Side of Vegetables $3.95 Side of Yellow Rice $3.95 Garlic Bread $3.95 Catering Sliders 24 sliders. For full catering please call us! Lobster Roll Sliders $95.00 Crab Cake Sliders $95.00 Fried Shrimp Po Boy Sliders $75.00 Cheeseburger Sliders $75.00 Buttermilk Fried Chicken Sliders $75.00 Mini Portobello, Red Pepper & Mozzarella Sliders $75.00 Rib Eye w/ Horseradish Sliders $95.00 Beverages Canned Soda Choose from our selection. $1.75 Iced Tea $2.5 Virgin Pina Colada $6 Bottled Water $1.75