City Island Seafood Shack

Takeout Menu • 
Catering Menu • 

Our Menus

Loyalty Program

Earn 1 point for every dollar spent on online orders.
Once you accumulate 200 points, you will receive a reward in the amount of $10.00 towards any online order.

Redeem the coupon at any time by clicking Enter Coupon button at checkout.
When you register AFTER your first order - you will automatically be enrolled and start earning points.

Download Our App

Downloading our App is simple! Just log on to our web site from your phone and you will automatically be prompted to download our App. We will only prompt you the first 3 times you visit the site and then only every once in a while. Follow instructions and save to your home screen. Our logo in the form of an icon will then be stored on your home screen. Any time you feel like accessing our site or placing an order just click on the icon and you are on your way!

City Island Seafood Shack
Catering Menu
We deliver within 2 miles with a $1.99 delivery charge & a $1.99 online convenience charge. NO DELIVERIES BETWEEN 2PM & 5PM
Available: Mon - Sat 11:30 am to 9 pm, Sun 11:30am to 8 pm
Order Online

Mini Lump Crab Cake Sliders (24) $85
Shrimp Empanadillas (24) $65
Peel & Eat Shrimp (2lbs.) $65
Clams Casino (24) $50
Clams Oreganato (24) $50
Mussels in Spicy Tomato Sauce (2lbs.) $40
Calamari Salad (2lbs.) $35

Trays serve up to 10 people
Seven Fish Zuppa di Pesce
Lobster, shrimp, clams, mussels, scallops, calamari, scungilli.
Fried Lemon Pepper Flounder $75
Parmigiana Crusted Baked Cod $75
Shrimp Stuffed w/ Crabmeat $75
Shrimp Scampi over Linguini $75
Pan Seared Scallops $75
White Seafood Lasagna $75
Lobster Mac & Cheese $70
Powered by